Cigarette Burns
John Carpenter resumes his role as a master of horror for the television series with
Cigarette Burns, an ode to the power of the genre film's revelations of the viewers who watch those movies.
Cigarette Burns draws off of the mysteries of forbidden movies, those which have been deemed too extreme for mass consumption and have been relegated to the underworlds of the industry.
Carpenter's addition to the series owes as much to films like
Ringu as it does to the controversies of violent films brought up in David Cronenberg's
Videodrome. Norman Reedus plays Kirby, owner of a popular theater that runs old, underground horror classics. Known for his ability to track down any film no matter how rare it is, Kirby is employed by rich film collector Bellinger (Udo Kier) to find the infamous
La Fin Absolue du Monde, a video nasty that opened one time to mass hysteria and murders. The movie is said to have a certain power over the watcher, and anyone who looks for it will come under its spell.
Kirby does become entranced by the film, and although he says he doesn't want to watch it, he eventually does anyway. But during his search for the movie, he starts to see little cigarette burns like those on old projection films.
La Fin Absolue du Monde begins to play off of Kirby's dark past, focusing on the death of his girlfriend and her addiction to heroin. These vignettes are interesting, although Carpenter doesn't do enough work delving into Kirby's past for the viewer to feel for his pain after witnessing these experiences. Instead, we get fleeting glimpses of the tragedy, and a subtle feeling that what Kirby experiences is painful, even if it seems somewhat shallow to the viewer.
The suspense builds as Kirby hunts down the film, tracking it through multiple individuals who have an idea of where it is but want to hide its final resting place; ultimately, these clues result in the person giving Kirby a new contact, but ineffectually giving advice that boils down to, "You'd best leave this matter alone because you won't like what you find." The aura given to
La Fin Absolue du Monde is intriguing and well-rendered, if somewhat easily generated because of the multiple warnings Kirby receives during his search.
Carpenter, however, attempts to incorporate too many factors into this film that become overtly and painfully existential in their mumbo-jumbo. Something about an actor's soul being tied to the film is introduced to us from the beginning of the film as a thin blue chained man resides in Bellinger's estate. This comes a bit too early for my taste; the introduction of the more supernatural aspects of the film would be more effective if they came later, after the initial tension of the multiple warnings.
There's also some hallucinatory vampirization involved which, despite being a nice reference to the Nosferatu sequence in
Are You Afraid of the Dark?, feels out of place considering the nature of
La Fin Absolue du Monde and the previous descriptions of acts committed. And finally, the mumbo-jumbo of living and dying while watching the film and the problems of seeing said film that comes too close to human reality while having to kill each other to make things right becomes confusing and unresolved in the climax. Should we watch the film to understand human nature? Does it hold secrets to the afterlife, to a holy Creator? Or is it just a movie created by a madman, which carries with it a paranormal evil that influences the viewer? It's not clear, and I'd like to know specifically if watching the film carries some existential significance - because if so, it's much more powerful to think that one must kill oneself lest be overcome with knowledge than it is to think it was some psychopath creating a snuff film.
And that's the main problem with
Cigarette Burns. The mystique behind the video nasty is intense but it spirals out of control in the finale, specifically because Carpenter attempts to show the viewer some of the film. What we see is not convincing - a black-and-white flick that looks like a cross between a snuff film and
Begotten. Sure, it might be disturbing and experimental, but it simply doesn't hit the expectations that have been created throughout
Cigarette Burns.
Slash to the Point: This is one of the better Masters of Horror episodes I've seen, even if it does falter in its final third. The build is creepy and shifty, and Carpenter intricately designs the film as a questionnaire for the viewer. If we were offered the chance to watch a film with such a horrific background, would we be curious enough to do it? And is that a good or a bad thing? We don't really get the answers with
Cigarette Burns except that everyone ends up dead, but it's a fun journey all the same.