I know that this is ridiculously late, and most of you have already tuned in for this anti-climactic, utterly disappointing finale to a show that couldn't really get much lower in my eyes. If you have, I invite you to join me as we finish up American Horror Story's first season; it will be back for a second, although how long it will last is anyone's guess.
When we last left the Harmons, almost everyone was dead. Vivien died in a particularly nasty childbirth, Viollet was already dead thanks to an overdose, and Ben was dead from the chest up with the only working thing on him being his groin. I could argue that everyone was mentally dead to begin with, but I think I'd be beating a dead horse there. Ben's now got a baby with no mother, and he struggles with what to do with him. Obviously suicide flits through his mind, although Constance stops by to play the nurturing, caring neighbor who certainly knows what's best for children (because, you know, she has none now) and talks him out of it. Ah, but it's not all easy within this haunted house, as Ben attempts to leave when he gets the blessing from Vivien and Violet in ghost form; Hayden has him murdered by a couple of people we don't really get to see, and then Ben returns to the house as a ghost and Constance takes their baby.
All of this happens in the first half of this episode, which was a surprise to me because I thought it would take the writers the entire episode to have Ben commit to killing himself. The surprise is soon decimated by this episode's tedium, however, because American Horror Story shows just how easy it is to reboot the series by bringing in another happy family, tearing them apart with almost every single ghost you've ever seen in the show, and then driving them out again. Easy, shmeezy, and the sad part is that the quick recap of the basics of what happened in this season happen in about twenty minutes. The haunted house gimmick to scare away the new family is decidedly entertaining, and that's because it almost feels like a mockery of the show itself; ironically, American Horror Story seems to do satirical impersonations of itself better than an actual horror story.
Hey, did I mention that Constance gets a baby? She sure does, because "Afterbirth" features a number of unending monologues from Constance about how this baby is her reason for living (I guess that Tate and Addy were rejects from God) that are so cloying that I was tempted to fast-forward.
The season ends on an interesting note, hinting that the devilish baby brought into the world by Vivien is actually the baby that survived. Now Constance has him in her care, and apparently he likes to murder things and point at them - this might have been the best part of the episode thanks to the little boy, who is pretty goddam cute as he gestures innocently to the woman bleeding all over his nursery.
But what's most disappointing about this episode, besides the season preceding it, is that it plays the whole thing extremely safe. Rebooting the series in the last episode, which plays out exactly like what happened to the Harmons? Simply killing off the family? These are things that people assumed from the outset, but it's not what they really wanted to happen until they found out how annoying and nonsensical the Harmons would be. The show was unceasingly frustrating all season long, but this conclusion ended the Horror Story on an extremely horrific low.






























